Virgil vs homer in underworld

Homer, Virgil, and the Theology of the Underworld

Homer does not mention this. For Aeneas, the sacrifices are like a key, he opens the door and walks through Hell. Those who over stepped the mark, like Clytemnestra, brought disgrace on all their sex — or so at least says Agamemnon. This, too, may make him a greater hero than Odysseus. Odysseus fears that Persephone will send some such creature and runs away before she can.

Odysseus proceeds to fight off these suitors, killing them so he can have his home back. Odysseus, on the other hand, although his journey does not seem as difficult, must complete it entirely on his own. Odysseus may not be able to meet his father in the Underworld because he is still at home, on his farm, mourning for Odysseus and, if Homer did indeed compose Book 24 of the Odyssey, then Odysseus must meet him and there finish the reconciliation that must take place for the poem to be rounded off successfully.

Aeneas also described the souls that were suffering and lost, but they did not have the same perilous and unknowing Virgil vs homer in underworld. Aeneas also only really meets men, although there are some women in the Morning Fields, who died for love, which, you get the feeling, was frowned upon by people of the time, else their pain would be relieved in the after life.

For Virgil, the Underworld must be categorized and organized as well as justified: This is typical of the views held by the heroes, as we have seen: However, Odysseus pours his into a trench, and waits for the souls to come to him.

If their lives were tormented i. The Aeneid is a book about fate, about the gods, about religion, about hubris, about the greatness of Rome.

Another significant difference that can be seen in the cataloging of lost souls set out by Virgil and Homer is the different approach the two have to the ordering of their worlds. To get in Hell, both men have to make sacrifices.

To Homer, there is nothing good in dying. But then, The Odyssey is not a book about that.

He is covered in wounds given to him by the Greeks. Hera was the goddess who used everything in her power to delay Aeneas from ever fulfilling his prophecy since Aeneas was a Trojan, and Hera had a hatred for the Trojans ever since the Trojan prince Paris gave a golden apple to Aphroditestating that she was the most beautiful out of her, Athena and Hera.

For Homer, there is comparatively little ritual: There is no mention of the greater glory of Ithaca, or Telemachus, because there is no need. Aeneas, on the other hand, exhibits his forward-looking vision and concern for fulfilling his destiny upon encountering his friend, the recently drowned Palinarus, and quickly wants to know: Not once is there a mention of the acts perpetrated by Pyrrhus in the Aeneid: Odysseus, however, never sees those lucky souls who will later become men; his experiences are confined to reliving the past, chatting with Achilles about the past glories of the Trojan War and lamenting the deaths of the many brave men there.

When, Aeneas was in the underworld the sections were clearly detailed and the descriptions of the places and the people were very vivid.Among the host of ways Virgil modifies and develops Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey, the changes wrought to the underworld are arguably the most substantial.

A complex geography forms of punishment.

Odysseus and Aeneas both visit the Underworld; in Odysseus' case, in Book XII of Homer's Odyssey, and in Aeneas' case, in Book VI of Virgil's Aeneid.

In discussing the differences between the two treatments of the Underworld episodes, it is imporcant to first outline the similarities in the two. Virgil vs. Homer in Underworld Essay  How does Virgil deviate from Homer in the underworld, and why?

When comparing “The Aeneid” to “The Odyssey”, it is impossible not to notice the similarity between Homer and Virgil's poems. To add weight to his poem (and to be seen as writing in the Homeric style) Vergil uses many similar scenes throughout his poem to those in Homer’s.

Homer, Virgil, and the Theology of the Underworld

For example, Odysseus meets his mother (who he does not know has died) in the Underworld. Com pare the visits to the Underworld by Odysseus and Aeneas. How does each poet explain the meaning of life and death? What values are important to Homer, and what are important to Vergil?. The visits of both these heroes to the Underworld come almost exactly in the middle of the poems.

Odysseus and Aeneas both visit the Underworld; in Odysseus' case, in Book XII of Homer's Odyssey, and in Aeneas' case, in Book VI of Virgil's Aeneid.

In discussing the differences between the two treatments of the Underworld episodes, it is imporcant to first outline the similarities in the two.

Download
Virgil vs homer in underworld
Rated 5/5 based on 38 review