An analysis of a controversial ethical issue using three main theories of ethics

However, Kant argued that there is a more foundational principle of duty that encompasses our particular duties.

On this model, the agent becomes part of the situation and acts caringly within that context. Duty Theories Many of us feel that there are clear obligations we have as human beings, such as to care for our children, and to not commit murder.

Healthcare News

While there are some ethical theorists who believe that normative claims are demonstrable either through experience or reasonother ethical theorists and most all logicians argue that it is impossible to prove that normative statements are true and so consider ethical arguments to be incomplete.

Hobbes, Thomas, Leviathan, ed. Norton Oxford; New York: Most generally, a "right" is a justified claim against another person's behavior - such as my right to not be harmed by you see also human rights.

If a person says something is good or bad they are telling us about the positive or negative feelings that they have about that something. Includes position sheet and scoring table. Moral values, they argued, are strictly human inventions, a position that has since been called moral relativism.

On the one side of the dispute, 18th century British philosopher David Hume argued that moral assessments involve our emotions, and not our reason. In addition to espousing skepticism and relativism, this-worldly approaches to the metaphysical status of morality deny the absolute and universal nature of morality and hold instead that moral values in fact change from society to society throughout time and throughout the world.

Ockham, William of, Fourth Book of the Sentences, tr. Utilitarianism also called consequentialism is a moral theory developed and refined in the modern world in the writings of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill This is a serious obstacle since, unless it is possible to 'prove' normative claims, it will be impossible to have sound ethical arguments.

One of the big questions in moral philosophy is whether or not there are unchanging moral rules that apply in all cultures and at all times.

Biomedical ethics focuses on a range of issues which arise in clinical settings. Is this statement true?

Ethics Theories: Utilitarianism Vs. Deontological Ethics

Suffice it to say that the majority of moral philosophers and theologians have found it defective. In recent years applied ethical issues have been subdivided into convenient groups such as medical ethics, business ethics, environmental ethicsand sexual ethics.

Finally, there are issues of social morality which examine capital punishment, nuclear war, gun control, the recreational use of drugs, welfare rights, and racism.

Table of Contents

The principles of autonomy, justice, and the various rights are based on moral rights. They believe that relativism respects the diversity of human societies and responds to the different circumstances surrounding human acts. Medieval philosophers commonly grouped all moral principles together under the heading of "eternal law" which were also frequently seen as spirit-like objects.

Critical Reasoning Analysis Provides a way for students to critically analyze information or an ethical issue using the elements of thought. The usual boundaries are personal what one person considers moral another might consider immoral, and neither is more correct than the other or culrural what is moral in one culture might be immoral in another culture, and neither is more correct that the other.

It is immoral to act with the direct intention to kill an innocent human being. Aristotle, Nichomachean Ethics, in Barnes, Jonathan, ed. The doctrine that the good is that which works both to increase personal satisfaction and to resolve group tensions.

Controversial issues of sexual morality include monogamy versus polygamy, sexual relations without love, homosexual relations, and extramarital affairs.

Do ethical statements provide information about anything other than human opinions and attitudes? We should do to others what we would want others to do to us.

In theory, resolving particular applied ethical issues should be easy. The Golden Rule is a classic example of a normative principle: To illustrate the difference consider the statements: Addressing end-of-life issues Nancy Berlinger, PhD, a research scholar with the Hastings Center, noted that end-of-life issues will also grow in importance as the population ages.

Metaethical analysis raises no special philosophical or logical problems. In a sense, it is a search for an ideal litmus test of proper behavior. Active euthanasia involves the direct intention to kill an innocent human being. If a given abortion produces greater benefit than disbenefit, then, according to act-utilitarianism, it would be morally acceptable to have the abortion.

With courage, for example, if I do not have enough courage, I develop the disposition of cowardice, which is a vice. This view is called psychological altruism and maintains that at least some of our actions are motivated by instinctive benevolence.Ethical (Moral) Theories We use ethical/moral theories to help us understand ethical cases and ethical Ethical Theories • Virtue Ethics • Duty Ethics • Right Ethics • Utilitarianism Cost-Benefit Analysis () • Is really an application of utilitarianism.

Ethical, Social, and Legal Issues OBJECTIVES Apply theories and principles of ethics to ethical dilemmas. 2. Describe how the steps of the nursing process can be applied to ethical decision making.

3. Ethical reasoning is the analysis of what is morally right and reasonable. Bioethics is the application of. The literature on “caring” theories of ethics that has grown out of Carol Gilligan's work on responses to moral situations provides another model that seeks to incorporate a greater emphasis on emotions and relationships.

Ethics Primer

29 Gilligan's psychological research has its parallels in philosophical ethics. Finally, applied ethics involves examining specific controversial issues, such as abortion, infanticide, animal rights, environmental concerns, homosexuality, capital punishment, or nuclear war.

By using the conceptual tools of metaethics and normative ethics, discussions in applied ethics try to resolve these controversial issues. Overview of Moral Theories: Analysis and Common Criticisms.

Some moral theories are presented in brief. Background for this Article. This thin guide to ethical theory was prepared for a course called "Philosophy of Peace" which I taught at Queen's University in This document can be used as an intro to ethics by activists, or by instructors in courses, especially where only a basic.

Ethical theories in business are important for everyone, business owners and customers and everyone else in between. Some ethical theories include sense of duty, business self-interest, and whether business leaders should be guided by their compassion or consequences.

An analysis of a controversial ethical issue using three main theories of ethics
Rated 3/5 based on 90 review